‘You Are the Apple of My Eye’ Review《那些年,我們一起追的女孩》 – What it’s like to be a dull person in Taiwan…

56643687201201100009304260813441392_000

The nicest thing one can say about this film is that it gives an idea of what it was like growing up as a straight boy in Taiwan for the generation born in the 1980s, or at least an idealized “idol drama” version of it – but I think that this is done in a more interesting way in Eternal Summer (《盛夏光年》), which incorporates a gay story line and has more complex character development beyond the Taiwanese “everyman” represented in this film  and even Winds of September (《九降風》). Based on a short story by Giddens Ko, a Taiwanese blogger-cum-novelist, You Are the Apple of My Eye is an extended idol drama, a dreary recounting of the author’s high school and university years. The humor in the film incorporates several wank jokes reminiscent of American Pie, but in this film these just came off as weird as the film tries to be an idol drama and The Inbetweeners at the same time, so the protagonist is a compromise between the typical  Taiwanese drama male lead and an inbetweeners-style comically unself-aware weirdo and the balance didn’t quite work here, as he just came off as cocky. 

I was left questioning what the message of the film was, as women in the film are only really valued in terms of how attractive they are to the opposite sex. Wafa Ghermani wrote an interesting piece on this marginalization of female characters in eRenlai here, including the following passage:

The only recent film that plays with this peripheral aspect is You’re the Apple of My Eye, indeed by adopting the narrator’s point of view, the film endorses the young hero’s gaze on his classmate. She, herself is deprived of an existence outside the hero’s gaze but she is both peripheral and central to the narration. This narrative stance allows the main character to create an ideal female who still escapes his understanding. The film establishes a distance and a game between the external image of the heroine, and the life of the hero. Whilst the heroine is seen as a smooth surface without any real desire or lust, the male character is shown with an overactive body. The heroine is seen, described, talked about but does not have a direct active role in the narration. Still the female character remains someone alive, in opposition to many ghostly characters.

The friendship between the high school boys in the film also seemed to be quite superficial – essentially whenever the protagonist turns his back for two seconds, the other guys try to swoop in to steal his girl. The only real lesson the film seemed to be preaching was that fat people aren’t trustworthy (and that they piss in their cars?). The film has the same feel as many other films by younger directions, some are a lot worse but many are better.

Rating: 1/5

As this is one of the only Taiwanese film I’ve reviewed thus far (although I’ve reviewed some on my old blog here), I don’t want to discourage people from checking out what Taiwan cinema has to offer. So I’ve listed some worthwhile Taiwanese films below:

A One And A Two 《一一》

Seven Days in Heaven 《父後七日》

Voices of Orchid Island 《蘭嶼觀點》

Goodbye Dragon Inn 《不散》

I Don’t Want to Sleep Alone 《黑眼圈》

The River 《河流》

What Time Is It There? 《你那邊幾點》

Dust in the Wind 《戀戀風塵》

The Puppetmaster 《戲夢人生》

The Personals 《徵婚啟事》

Secret Love in Peach Blossom Land 《暗戀桃花源》

A Borrowed Life 《多桑》

Formula 17 《17歲的天空》

5 thoughts on “‘You Are the Apple of My Eye’ Review《那些年,我們一起追的女孩》 – What it’s like to be a dull person in Taiwan…

  1. I agree with your review and the passage quoted from erenlai. What struck me when I saw the movie was that the marginalization of girls enshroud them in an aura of mystery that keeps them respected, but also “out of reach” as if boys and men never could start on equal footing a relationship with the opposite sex.

  2. Pingback: ‘You Are the Apple of My Eye’ Review《那些年,我們一起追的女孩》 – What it’s like to be a dull person in Taiwan… | ChineseSpeakers

  3. I must agree with your review, but when I watch it, there is a fundamental stupidity that is definitely seen in Taiwanese teens that I relate and understand from the film’s style of characterisation. It captures well the elements of “38” ness that silly people in reality do embody so much (or at least try). It feels incredibly nostalgic.

    That being said, the marginalisation of women as love objects, the way that Taiwanese courting (between most hetero relationships, but not uncommon in homosexual lesbian relationships) works is pretty well displayed in film as well. There’s a ridiculous unwillingness to admit affection, yet there is unwavering dedication and commitment devoted to “chasing” or “追” your object of desire. Love is shown through buying food or taking the blame for things. It is calling them everyday and being an active presence. The protagonist is an idiotic macho dude, but I see a lot of my friends in his noodle-like comedic behaviour. I think this is also why it was such a popular movie in Taiwan.

    I think the quality of cinema is fairly poor, but it is a film that shows some fundamental traits of teenage love in Taiwan and its’ private relationship dynamics from a single perspective.

  4. Just watched the show on DVD last night…Nice movie reminded us about our good old days during secondary school we do have our liking of girls. I believe some could have been grandma by now 😉 Lol
    One thing about the movie i really can’t stand is the main actor walking around his house fully naked and his parents looks like nothing happen. I wonder Is it a Taiwanese culture youths walking naked at home ?? LOL

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s